Home

Page

Town Board

Meeting Reports

Town

Finances

Growth

Issues

Milan

In The Press

Business
Directory

Community

News & Events

Government

Directory & Schedules

Political

Scene

 

Hearing Reports

 

First Durst Hearing

February 6, Pine Plains

 

Second Durst Hearing

  February 29, Pine Plains

 

Third Durst Hearing

March 6, Milan

 

Fourth Durst Hearing

March 12, Pine Plains

 

Fifth Durst Hearing

April 5, Pine Plains

 




 

Durst Carvel photo

 

Roll over with your mouse for a quick look at the proposed look of the project.

 

 

Where Things Stand on Zoning

A Report from Pine Plains United

August 2009

 

We are writing you to bring you up to date with what has happened since the hearings ended this spring. The Town Board dismissed most of the requests by PPU members and experts related to dropping the NND section, placement of single houses, etc. But they have made a number of revisions to the law, the most significant of which are:

 

* Increase the amount of permanently protected open space in an NND to 60% of the unconstrained land from 50%..

* Not allow land already in conservation easement to be included in an NND application.

* Allow for commercial uses on the flat part of the Village Green

ield behind Stewart's.

 

Housing density concerns discussed

Pine Plains board works to revise zoning plan

 

Town officials gathered last week to consider potential changes to the town's zoning law, making big strides toward final approval.The town board workshop focused entirely on addressing the concerns expressed by residents about the proposed zoning law.Planner Bonnie Franson reviewed about 160 people's comments, 50 to 60 of which were from non-residents, and boiled them down into major categories and specific issues to review.The majority of concerns addressed the inclusion of the New Neighborhood Design."The real concern has to do with density," Franson said...

Poughkeepsie Journal May 20, 2009... READ

 

Pine Plains closing in on zoning law

We’ll try to make this as painless as possible for you,” Replansky told Town Board members as they began reviewing the zoning proposal. “Even for people who do this for a living, it’s difficult to understand.

Daiy Freeman Dec 26 2008 ...READ

Criticisms of the Project from Consultants

 

Numerous consultants provided expert critiques of aspects of the DEIS. Most but by no means all were hired by Pine Plains United. Taken as a whole, the criticisms are a devastating indictment of the many deep flaws in the project. We’ve cited them and linked to them in the hearing reports and list them here to make it easier for you to find them. They’re in very approximate chronological order.

 

George Janes report on visual impacts

 

George Janes photos

 

Greenwash letter from Dutchess County Department of Planning and Development

 

Letter from Roger Akeley to PPPB

 

Comments by Ross Williams at the hearing on March 6

 

Camoin Associates peer review of Chapter 14, Community Services and Fiscal Impacts

 

ELAN analysis of Chapter 3, Land Use and Zoning, and Chapter 7, Community Character and Visual Impacts

 

Comments by Lauren Kingman, member Milan Planning Board

 

Comments by David Clouser, PE on engineering aspects

 

Comments by John Lyons addressing the completeness issue

 

Comments by Ross Williams at final hearing

 

 

 

Informational Meeting ... Draft Zoning and Durst-Carvel

 

We attended an informational meeting of the Pine Plains Planning Board on April 15 to learn more about the draft zoning law, and in particular, about the New Neighborhood Development (NND) portion of the law and how it will affect the Durst/Carvel project. The short answer is, the NND seems tailor-made for Durst in every respect. It’s not necessarily a bad concept, because it’s based on traditional neighborhood design and it incorporates a lot of good planning ideas. The problem is that it brings us right back to the main issue with the Durst project: It’s just too big. The NND proposal would allow a maximum of 611 new homes on the property. Add that to the possible total in the Milan portion and the number comes to 675 new homes. READ MORE

 

 

Remove the NND

 

The New Neighborhood Development (NND) chapter of the Pine Plains draft zoning law seems to have been written for the express purpose of helping Durst develop the Carvel property with 675 homes.

The chapter is an unneccessary gift to Durst. That's what John Lyons, attorney for Pine Plains United, thinks, and it's also what Lisa Nagle, head planner for Elan and a PPU consultant, thinks. They've written important letters to the Pine Plains Town Board expressing their concerns in detail and recommending that the NND chapter simply be eliminated from the draft zoning law .

You can read them here:

 

John Lyons letter and the Elan Letter

both written to the Pine Plains Town Board

 

Housing density concerns discussed

Pine Plains board works to revise zoning plan

 

Town officials gathered last week to consider potential changes to the town's zoning law, making big strides toward final approval.The town board workshop focused entirely on addressing the concerns expressed by residents about the proposed zoning law.Planner Bonnie Franson reviewed about 160 people's comments, 50 to 60 of which were from non-residents, and boiled them down into major categories and specific issues to review.The majority of concerns addressed the inclusion of the New Neighborhood Design."The real concern has to do with density," Franson said...

 

Poughkeepsie Journal May 20, 2009... READ

 

 

Pine Plains Zoning Update April 2009

by Sheila Buff

 

We attended an informational meeting of the Pine Plains Planning Board on April 15 to learn more about the draft zoning law, and in particular, about the New Neighborhood Development (NND) portion of the law and how it will affect the Durst/Carvel project. The short answer is, the NND seems tailor-made for Durst in every respect. It’s not necessarily a bad concept, because it’s based on traditional neighborhood design and it incorporates a lot of good planning ideas. The problem is that it brings us right back to the main issue with the Durst project: It’s just too big. The NND proposal would allow a maximum of 611 new homes on the property. Add that to the possible total in the Milan portion and the number comes to 675 new homes.

 

We urge you to read this section of the draft zoning law for yourself at the Pine Plains town website

 

The part you want is Local Law #1, section 100-28. If you can, read it and attend the second public hearing in Pine Plains on Wednesday, April 22, starting at 7 p.m., at the Lions Club Pavilion (82 Beach Road). Speak up about the excessive size allowed by the NND—your opinion, even though you’re not a Pine Plains resident, still counts.

 

If you can’t make the meeting, please send written comments to Town Supervisor, Town of Pine Plains, Pine Plains Town Hall, 3284 Route 199, PO Box 955, Pine Plains, NY 12567. You have until the close of the business day on May 4th to submit your comments. READ MORE

 

 

 

MORE DURST PRESS HERE

© 2009 MilanInsider.com